To counteract the tax avoidance ‘flip flop’ schemes that were popular in the 1990s/early 2000s, Schedule 4B and 4C were introduced. While the two pieces of legislation often do go hand-in-hand, Sch. 4B can apply standalone.
Background to ‘flip flop’ schemes
These schemes used loans between trusts to avoid tax that would have been payable by the UK resident settlor or UK resident beneficiaries when the trust disposed of an asset. The schemes generally came in two different versions:
1. Avoidance of settlor interested trust provisions (s86) - A UK resident settlor who is not excluded is taxed on the gains of the trust as it arises. Steps designed to avoid s86 were:
2. Avoidance of matching of gains (s87) - Gains of the trust are matched to distributions to UK resident beneficiaries which gives rise to tax payable by the recipient beneficiary. Steps designed to avoid s87 were:
Schedule 4B conditions:
The legislation is actually more wide-reaching than it needs to be to counteract the 'flip flop' schemes, which involved the transfer of trust property from one to another; Schedule 4B applies to any transfer of value from the Trust i.e. transfer of trust property, loan, distribution.
Where the 3 conditions above apply, there is a deemed disposal of the chargeable assets of the trust at their market value. This does not include assets of any underlying companies, it is just the Trust’s assets.
The value of chargeable assets, i.e. the deemed proceeds, is likely to be pro-rated where there are differences in the amount of trustee borrowing and transfer of value. The pro-rata calculation is also used for the base cost of the assets being disposed.
Where there is a pro-rated deemed proceeds the trust’s assets will be left with a blended base cost. If the trust is settlor-interested i.e. has a UK resident non-excluded settlor, the gain will be taxable on the settlor. If the trust is not settlor-interested, the gain must be recorded by the trustees’.
Schedule 4C conditions:
Any gains arising on the Sch 4B deemed disposal that have not been taxed on the settlor are transferred into a stockpiled gains pool, known as the Sch 4C pool.
This pool operates in the same way as the s87 stockpiled gains pool but Schedule 4C takes priority. This means that any stockpiled gains in the s87 pool up to the date of the Sch4B transfer are ‘tipped’ into the Sch 4C pool.
Distributions to UK resident beneficiaries are ‘matched’ to the Sch 4C gains and the beneficiaries are taxed personally. Trust gains made after the Sch 4B transfer will go into the s87 pool as normal. No tax return is required for the trust and any reporting is completed through the beneficiaries’ personal tax returns. However, it is important for trustees to keep a record of the pools so they can inform the beneficiaries accordingly.
The key difference between the Sch 4C and s87 pools is that distributions to non-UK resident beneficiaries do not reduce the stockpiled gains of Sch 4C.
However, this difference may be removed as this same rule for s87 gains, that distributions to non-UK residents will not reduce the stockpiled gains, was included within the Finance Bill 2017. This was one of the changes pulled out of the 2017 Finance Bill but it is widely believed that this will be reintroduced after the General Election in June 2018.